This is my third Cather novel, and it stands out from the others in that it follows a more traditionally structured narrative. However, the praise of the American West/pioneering spirit and the love for nature are still evident and make it clearly “a Cather”.
The novel tells the story of Mrs. Forrester, a captivating and enigmatic woman, as seen through the eyes of the local young men who admire her, particularly Niel Herbert, the narrator. Marian seems like a breath of fresh air, an elegant woman, lost in the unsophisticated settlement sprung up by the railroad.
Though Niel’s perspective dominates, we also get glimpses from others. Niel’s admiration for the Forresters is evident, and his near-heroic intensity spills onto the page as he observes them from afar, projecting values and ideas onto the gentle and successful Mr Forrester and his younger wife. Niel’s compassion and judgement interplay in how the relationship develops.
One of the most compelling aspects of the novel is its commentary on social change, particularly the shifting roles of women. I wished it delved deeper into Mrs. Forrester’s inner world and her past. Cather’s prose is masterful, and the novel offers a fascinating exploration of social decline, class shifts, and the struggles of those who lose wealth and status. Witnessing Mrs. Forrester’s gradual descent in society is both tragic and powerful, leading to a particularly striking ending.
There are brief references to racism and theft of indigenous lands. However, these themes are overshadowed by the story of settlers and their fortunes. It would be interesting to examine A Lost Lady or Cather’s other works from this perspective.
Ageing is something else that this novel explores with intelligence, as well as the difficulties of goodbyes.
I really enjoyed the introduction to this edition, which provided insightful discussions on Willa Cather’s place in the American literary canon. Cather is hard to “pin down”, but that is what makes her work so interesting.
One word: deft.
Leave a Comment